ObamaCare is heading toward a death spiral. The administration is having trouble selling insurance plans to healthy people. That’s a big problem: When the young and healthy don’t enroll, premiums have to be hiked to cover the costs of older and sicker people, discouraging even more young people from signing up.
Last Thursday, the administration predicted enrollment for 2016 will be less than half what had been forecast in March by the Congressional Budget Office.
Even with subsidies to help with premiums and out-of-pocket costs, most of the uninsured who are eligible for ObamaCare are saying “no thanks.” Only one in seven is expected to sign up. That’s despite a hefty increase in the financial penalty next year for not having insurance.
The administration seems reconciled to failure. Already it has announced it won’t be running the customary nationwide TV campaign to encourage sign-ups, as in previous years.
Remember the young guy in plaid pajamas — “Pajama Boy” to conservatives? Well, he won’t be back this winter.
Bad enough that healthy people aren’t buying. Worse is that the administration is spending billions of your tax dollars covering up the problem, paying insurers to keep offering the plans, even though they’re losing their shirts. But facts are facts — and there’s no hiding these.
Health and Human Services Secretary Sylvia Burwell predicts Obama-Care enrollment will inch up by 1 million or so, to 10 million people — half what the CBO forecast. Open enrollment for the coming year, which begins Nov. 1, “is going to be a challenge,” she said.
David Wichmann, UnitedHealth Group’s president, announced higher premiums last week because enrollees will “require more medical services than original expectations.”
Many states are looking at premium hikes of 30% or more, according to a new Robert Wood Johnson/Urban Institute analysis. The Heritage Foundation estimates that insurers lost 12% selling ACA plans in 2014, with more losses this year.
Don’t shed any tears for the insurance companies. Though they’re losing money on exchange plans, they’re profitable overall, and their stocks are doing well. It’s John Q. Public who’s bearing the brunt. Just as ObamaCare intended.
If you get insurance at work, you’re paying an extra tax to fund “reinsurance” for ObamaCare plans. It’s a fund to defray the cost of their most expensive enrollees.
So far, insurers have collected $7.9 billion. Recent congressional testimony shows the payments kept ObamaCare sticker prices about 11% lower than they otherwise would have been. In short, you pay a tax to make Obama-Care look more affordable than it is.
But even with these hidden subsidies, ObamaCare isn’t working because the design is fatally flawed. The 5% of the population with serious medical conditions consume nearly 50% of the health care. When you try to sell insurance to sick and healthy people for the same price, the healthy don’t sign up. It’s too expensive.
New York State learned that in the 1990s, when one-price-for-all insurance laws pushed premiums to the highest in the nation, crushing the individual insurance market here.
ObamaCare repeats that mistake. Despite slapping the uninsured with penalties — which will jump to 2.5% of household income in 2016 — they’re not signing up. The need to coerce enrollment with penalties is proof the plans are a bad deal.
How long will big insurers play along? There are political considerations, and for most, ObamaCare losses are still just a dent in their overall business. Not so for the 23 co-op insurers set up under the health law. Eight state plans have already failed, including New York’s Health Republic, and most of the rest are bleeding money.
With ObamaCare enrollment floundering and losses mounting, the nation needs alternatives. The Republicans are coalescing around a reform plan, but Democrats are doubling down.
Hillary Rodham Clinton wants to burden the existing, unpopular plans with more “free” goodies and make it harder to dodge the mandate. That won’t work. A real reform should cover the seriously ill — people with pre-existing conditions — in separate plans with separate pricing and subsidies to make them affordable.
Just like the high-risk pools many states used to maintain. That’s the lesson of ObamaCare’s failure.
• McCaughey is author of “Beating ObamaCare” and a senior fellow at the London Center for Policy Research.
‘Playing on stupidity of the American voter is how we got it passed’